LWN.net Logo

...and if SCO is right...?

...and if SCO is right...?

Posted May 16, 2003 21:12 UTC (Fri) by ctg (subscriber, #3459)
Parent article: ...and if SCO is right...?

I've never seen any organisation with a "process" to ensure that code really belongs to
the author.

Code is created by individuals. It would be almost impossible not to use the lessions,
techniques and idioms learned in one job/project, and not use them in another, for
example.

I'm pretty sure that if you looked at the closed sourced projects that I've been involved
with (i.e proprietry systems), you would find code produced by individuals that was
somewhat similar to the sort of code that they had produced for other projects...
belonging to another company with a different copyright.

Because the Linux development process is so open - that it is almost the best process
that I've come across for ensuring that blatant code duplication does not exist - it
would be too easy to it do be discovered. In a closed system there would be much less
risk of discovery.

Of course, the big risk for Linux is because the code is open it is easy for someone to
find "patterns" or areas of commonality...

I'm pretty sure that what SCO has found, if anything, is pretty much likely to be the
result of people simply applying the lessons, techniques etc. that they have acquired
during the course of their careers to problems in the Linux kernel.


(Log in to post comments)

...and if SCO is right...?

Posted May 19, 2003 10:22 UTC (Mon) by mdekkers (guest, #85) [Link]

IBM (of all companies...) has a rather tight set of processes in place to guard against "IPR leakeage" from its Open Source developers. The process ensures that code wrtitten and submitted by IBM either belongs to IBM and is cleared for donation, or does not belong to anyone else.

...and if SCO is right...?

Posted May 22, 2003 7:44 UTC (Thu) by Liefting (subscriber, #8466) [Link]

Code is created by individuals. It would be almost impossible not to use the lessions, techniques and idioms learned in one job/project, and not use them in another, for example.

Code is protected by copyright law. Lessons, techniques and idioms are protected by patent law. That's a totally different ballgame altogether.

Copyright © 2012, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds