LWN.net Logo

Theora 1.0 released

Theora 1.0 released

Posted Nov 6, 2008 10:03 UTC (Thu) by irios (guest, #19838)
Parent article: Theora 1.0 released

I understand that some of the changes in Thusnelda are improvements to the encoder that are actually within Theora 1.0 spec; these don't actually change the spec, but rather implement it better than in the current encoder -- things like actually using dynamic coefficient matrixes instead of ignoring them and using a fixed coefficient set. These improvements seem to bring Theora up to Xvid-like quality (quite a jump!), and seemingly could be folded into the existing encoder while maintaining decoder compatibility.

There are further improvements in Thusnelda that do exceed the Theora spec and will need to be described in an updated spec version.

The problem in all these seems to be that almost nobody actually uses Theora, so the interest level in it is low, and the developer love it receives is minimal -- Thusnelda, which is the bleeding edge of Theora development appears to be a one-person effort. The image quality Theora offers is also not very good, which closes the vicious circle.

Let's hope that its inclusion in Firefox will drive some dynamism into it. And let's also hope that it is conceptually good enough that it can be made competitive with other codecs, which also remains to be seen.


(Log in to post comments)

Wikipedia and Firefox support may ramp things up

Posted Nov 6, 2008 19:12 UTC (Thu) by dwheeler (guest, #1216) [Link]

Wikipedia requires free codecs, so Theora is what you're supposed to supply videos in (and Vorbis for audio). Wikipedia is one of the world's most popular sites. The new version of Firefox will include Theora support - and since that's a browser with millions of users, soon there will be lots of people who will be able to easily view Theora (and Vorbis).

I think that's a dynamic combination. Codecs are a chicken and egg problem - you need to get lots of readers AND lots of content for a codec to succeed. Wikipedia can provide content, Firefox can provide readers.... leading to a great potential for success.

Wikipedia and Firefox support may ramp things up

Posted Nov 8, 2008 10:30 UTC (Sat) by pointwood (guest, #2814) [Link]

You also need simple and easy to use tools to create Theora videos. Otherwise, few people will be posting videos in Theora.

Copyright © 2012, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds