LWN.net Logo

AbiWord team interview (Red Hat Magazine)

AbiWord team interview (Red Hat Magazine)

Posted May 12, 2008 8:53 UTC (Mon) by tialaramex (subscriber, #21167)
In reply to: AbiWord team interview (Red Hat Magazine) by jordanb
Parent article: AbiWord team interview (Red Hat Magazine)

As I've detailed before, what you actually commit to with any of these "open" formats is
recreating the internals of the program that "set the standard", in this case OpenOffice.org.
If their borders get 4 pixels bigger when the font is over 20 points then it doesn't matter
that the "standard" is silent about border thickness, that's what you've got to implement to
load their documents.

In the event that you allow other people to come forward and add things to the "standard" as
well you end up with a standard that no-one implements. That worked out really well for HTML 4
and CSS right ? Just a decade later we've got three half-working implementations which overlap
on maybe 90% of features and it's finally starting to be usable... except the 800lb gorilla
doesn't implement them properly so you still can't use most of it. HTML 4 and CSS is a /walk
in the park/ compared to a usefully complete word processor or spreadsheet document format.

To be compelling, ODF needed to take large, real world documents, and create several programs
which, without code-sharing displayed those documents the same way, and got the same results
from arbitrary changes to those documents.  That was never even /attempted/ let alone
successfully tried.


(Log in to post comments)

AbiWord team interview (Red Hat Magazine)

Posted May 12, 2008 10:54 UTC (Mon) by renox (guest, #23785) [Link]

[[As I've detailed before, what you actually commit to with any of these "open" formats is
recreating the internals of the program that "set the standard"]]

Apparently KOffice developers disagree with you, I (barely) remember an interview but they
said that when they find that OOo doesn't respect the ODF standard they simply file a bug
against OOo..
We're not talking working with Microsoft here!


Copyright © 2012, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds