LWN.net Logo

Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP)

Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP)

Posted Apr 23, 2008 8:46 UTC (Wed) by danieldk (subscriber, #27876)
In reply to: Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP) by rsidd
Parent article: Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP)

While I do think the OLPC could be great for textbooks, the question is who is going to write
high-quality textbooks and provide them cheaper than the prices that you already mentioned. Of
course, existing publishers could provide electronic books at a low price per pop (and make a
profit on the quantities). Suppose that these non-free textbooks are half the price of
on-paper textbooks for third world countries, you'll still many textbooks to cover the cost of
an XO machine.

Not to mention that dead tree books work better for extreme climates.

I think many people involved have noble intentions. And as a side effect, the XO has pushed
down prices for other laptops. But I am not sure whether an XO is a better investment than
text books, and maybe normal computers in a more protected environment (e.g. a classroom),
where they have a longer lifetime, and you don't need one machine per kid.


(Log in to post comments)

Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP)

Posted Apr 23, 2008 10:49 UTC (Wed) by jamesh (subscriber, #1159) [Link]

Who do you think currently writes the text books?  What do you think makes a text book sell?

If the education department for a country or state proscribes a text book that is available in
an electronic form, why would it sell any worse than if they proscribed a paper text book?

As the curriculum differs from country to country (or even state to state within a country),
the text books are often written by teachers from that region.  If electronic texts are being
proscribed, why wouldn't these same people write electronic text books?

Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP)

Posted Apr 23, 2008 15:48 UTC (Wed) by danieldk (subscriber, #27876) [Link]

Who do you think currently writes the text books? What do you think makes a text book sell? Sure, as I said, existing publishers. But they want good money for it, and even if the price is only half the ~$10 mentioned, you need to buy many textbooks to compensate the cost of an XO. So, why not buy dead-tree textbooks. (I was kinda aiming at, who is going to write Creative Commons-licensed textbooks ;).)

Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP)

Posted Apr 23, 2008 16:48 UTC (Wed) by macc (subscriber, #510) [Link]

commercial textbook creators are in for the margin.
just like with the overpriced dead tree educational 
merchandise.
A pdf version ( or other format) will be milked for 
the last <smallest monetary unit> that can be extracted
from the state.

G!
MACC

Low-cost laptop program sees a key leadership defection (AP)

Posted Apr 24, 2008 15:46 UTC (Thu) by BenHutchings (subscriber, #37955) [Link]

Spelling flame: there's a big difference between "prescribe" and "proscribe".

Copyright © 2008, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds