LWN.net Logo

OMFS and the value of obscure filesystems

OMFS and the value of obscure filesystems

Posted Apr 17, 2008 8:24 UTC (Thu) by simlo (subscriber, #10866)
Parent article: OMFS and the value of obscure filesystems

There is a lot of code which is rarely used in the kernel. Around 2.6.8-2.6.9 I needed a
driver (ArcNet) which clearly hadn't been used since some time in 2.5. But I fixed the bug,
submitted a patch and later on at least one other person have fixed a bug in the driver, and I
see a few janitory changes around.

Clearly not many people are using this driver. But because it was still in the mainline kernel
it was keeped up-to-date wrt. interface changes and compile-tested. It was untested and
contained a bug, which was fairly simple to fix. If the driver wasn't in the mainline, I am
pretty sure I would never had got around to get ArcNet to work in Linux at all, since it was
only a "private" experiment at my former job. 

I can't see why a file system should be different.

The only other way to make sure Linux supports a lot of old stuff, is to make a stable API and
be backward compatible. But how easy would it be to make it possible to (compile and) load a
2.4 driver into a 2.6 kernel with no modifications?
I am not even sure a "micro kernel" (like using fuse) approach would help much. The interfaces
might be much more stable, but over a long period they will be changed. But will they get
compiled checked as they are in Linux now?


(Log in to post comments)

fuse API stability

Posted Apr 17, 2008 11:05 UTC (Thu) by mszeredi (subscriber, #19041) [Link]

Backward compatibility in fuse is guaranteed on multiple levels:

 - the raw kernel interface 
 - the library ABI
 - the library API

While new major versions of the library might come out in the future, the old versions will
still be usable.  Just like gtk-1.2 libraries are still around in distributions, many years
after gtk-2.0 has been released.

I agree though, that in case of drivers where a userspace soultion is not available, keeping
support for old hardware in the kernel is a good thing.

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds