Gentoo 2008.0 beta delayed [LWN.net]

Gentoo 2008.0 beta delayed

Posted Mar 24, 2008 22:10 UTC (Mon) by bangert (subscriber, #28342)
In reply to: Gentoo 2008.0 beta delayed by pr1268
Parent article: Gentoo 2008.0 beta delayed

> I'm impressed at how quickly the Gentoo project got itself back 
> on track after a near-meltdown,

or perhaps, it was not even close to a melt-down at all...

(Log in to post comments)

Not close to melt-down

Posted Mar 25, 2008 2:52 UTC (Tue) by pr1268 (subscriber, #24648) [Link]

I dunno... I saw terms like "Crisis", "revocation of ... corporate license", "Gentoo collapsing", and "internal furor" on that page, and the first word that came to my mind was "meltdown."

Granted, I tend to over-dramatize and exaggerate things I read, so yes, I'll concede that perhaps "meltdown" was/is too harsh (and too inaccurate) a term here. Again, best of luck and wishes to the Gentoo team.

Not close to melt-down

Posted Mar 25, 2008 9:03 UTC (Tue) by sylware (subscriber, #35259) [Link]

A collective tried to take over gentoo control. But it seems they failed (where they clearly
succeeded with gnome).
You have to keep in mind that source based distros provide a flexibility that cannot be match
by binary distros. And of course it's way out of the league for proprietary software. Since
gentoo is the most popular source based distro, some collectives which cannot match its
flexibility have interest in sabotaging it in order to make it look bad. As far as I'm
concerned, gentoo intensity did not flick a second.

No melt-down on my 4 Gentoo systems...

Posted Mar 26, 2008 20:43 UTC (Wed) by Sycamore (guest, #50934) [Link]

First of all, my sympathies to those devs. There's more important things in Life than
computers and its always horrible if those things go wrong.. If you're reading this, just take
your time. We do miss the updates but we'll get along.

As for Gentoo, there was and is no meltdown. There was (and might still be) a PR meltdown. But
PR is a load of (insert long series of cursewords here) anyways. Under the scratched skin the
beast Gentoo is alive and well, with new kernels, new toolchains, new packages, new Portage
versions etc. I would've never even noticed this so-called meltdown if I hadn't been reading
the Gentoo Newsletter.

There have been disturbances, but name any democratic open source project of Gentoo's size
that doesn't "suffer" from the occasional flamewar... So what if we lost our registration with
some illegitimate government - who cares? It's not like we got confiscated by the government
like a certain major UK bank.

So in short: Yes, you are exaggerating :)