LWN.net Logo

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 11:06 UTC (Mon) by rossburton (subscriber, #7254)
In reply to: Nokia to acquire Trolltech by and
Parent article: Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Nokia are a Symbian shop who has a small division which uses GTK+.  Nokia sell something in
the order of hundred of millions of phones every nanosecond which all run Symbian.  As the
press release mentions S40/S60, my guess is that they are planning on re-invent Series 60 on
Qt.


(Log in to post comments)

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 11:18 UTC (Mon) by kripkenstein (subscriber, #43281) [Link]

> As the press release mentions S40/S60, my guess is that they are planning on re-invent
Series 60 on Qt.

Yes, that was my thinking as well - clearly there will be some connection to Nokia's S60
somehow. Perhaps it'll use Qt or some part of Qt, who knows. I'm sure Nokia has a specific
goal in mind when it decided on this move.

Not sure what Qt will bring, though - letting people code apps that are cross-platform and can
hence run on other platforms than S60 seems counterproductive for Nokia. Or perhaps Nokia was
concerned about competition from Qtopia? No idea. But it seems obvious that Nokia is primarily
interested in Trolltech for use on mobile devices (Nokia being, well, *Nokia*), and not on
desktop computers. What this means for KDE, time will tell.

P.S. Looks like I predicted this just last week, missing only by 5 years or so ;)
http://lwn.net/Articles/266069/

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 12:36 UTC (Mon) by jpetso (guest, #36230) [Link]

> P.S. Looks like I predicted this just last week, missing only
> by 5 years or so ;)
> http://lwn.net/Articles/266069/

Heh. I'd say they've read your comment and then instantly decided
on doing so :P

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 14:40 UTC (Mon) by nhippi (guest, #34640) [Link]

Not sure what Qt will bring, though - letting people code apps that are cross-platform and can hence run on other platforms than S60 seems counterproductive for Nokia.
  1. QT has Infinitely easier API than S60.
  2. QT has Infinitely more UI flexibility allowing Nokia to create much more sexy UI.
  3. Once all the apps run on QT, switching the kernel beneath is easier.
  4. Makes motorola managers scream when they realize they need to license Qtopia from Nokia if they want to continue building their future on the JUIX Linux/Qtopia/Java based platform ;)

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 17:42 UTC (Mon) by drag (subscriber, #31333) [Link]

5. Nokia gets to license the QT/Nokia platform to proprietary-software-making third parties
and control the platform.

If they move to the Linux kernel, decide to license to third parties, and is able to make QT
very attractive for developers they get a strong chance to unite the Linux mobile phone market
around their banner.

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 17:12 UTC (Mon) by sbishop (subscriber, #33061) [Link]

I don't follow Trolltech and KDE very closely, but I do know that Nokia is using WebKit in its
S60 phones:

http://opensource.nokia.com/projects/S60browser/

WebKit is the Apple fork of the KDE HTML library (KHTML) which Trolltech has recently decided
to include in Qt proper.  (WebKit is used in Apple's Safari browser, among others.)  The code
gets around.  :)  There's even been talk of using WebKit with Konqueror, taking it full
circle.

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 17:47 UTC (Mon) by drag (subscriber, #31333) [Link]

Two other webkit browsers for Linux that I've noticed is the Epiphany-webkit varient.. were
they swapped out Gecko for webkit (for the purpose of reducing resource usage for Gnome users)
and the Midori browser. 

For those people seeking a lightweight GTK-only C-only browser for their desktops should check
out Midori. Should go nice with XFCE when it's mature.


Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 20:21 UTC (Mon) by HoserHead (subscriber, #828) [Link]

I have two questions regarding Midori:

How is C-only a feature? Why would a user care what language his/her applications is
programmed in?

How is C-only possible? WebKit is written in C++.

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 20:37 UTC (Mon) by i3839 (subscriber, #31386) [Link]

It's using the Webkit version ported to GTK, WebkitGTK, and GTK is C.

Users should care in what language their software is written because if it's in a language
they don't know or like, they won't hack on it.

(And please no programming language flame war here, there are enough hooks to grab for the
bored and inclined. And no GTK versus Qt silliness either, thank you.)

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 21:59 UTC (Mon) by HoserHead (subscriber, #828) [Link]

Sure, GTK is C-only, but WebKit (even WebKit-GTK; WebKit is written in C++, even if its widget
bindings are written in C) isn't. It seems silly to ignore a hugely important component of a
web browser in its description.

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 28, 2008 23:34 UTC (Mon) by drag (subscriber, #31333) [Link]

Well C/C++ then. Doesn't realy matter to me.'

There isn't any higher level languages like XUL, Python, Mono, or whatnot being added to the
mix, which was my point. Should be very lightweight and being GTK should work well in other
minimalist environments and XFCE.. no big Gnome or KDE dependancies required.

Nokia to acquire Trolltech

Posted Jan 30, 2008 20:33 UTC (Wed) by i3839 (subscriber, #31386) [Link]

I tried Midori out, and it uses much less memory than Firefox (half or less), but it's as slow
or slower, at least rendering and scrolling. It also doesn't render all pages correctly, so
all in all it has a long way to go.

Copyright © 2008, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds