|| ||Andrew Morton <akpm-AT-linux-foundation.org>|
|| ||Abhishek Rai <abhishekrai-AT-google.com>,
|| ||Re: [CALL FOR TESTING] Make Ext3 fsck way faster [2.6.24-rc6 -mm
|| ||Tue, 15 Jan 2008 03:04:41 -0800|
I'm wondering about the real value of this change, really.
In any decent environment, people will fsck their ext3 filesystems during
planned downtime, and the benefit of reducing that downtime from 6
hours/machine to 2 hours/machine is probably fairly small, given that there
is no service interruption. (The same applies to desktops and laptops).
Sure, the benefit is not *zero*, but it's small. Much less than it would
be with ext2. I mean, the "avoid unplanned fscks" feature is the whole
reason why ext3 has journalling (and boy is that feature expensive during
So... it's unobvious that the benefit of this feature is worth its risks
to post comments)