Weekly edition	Kernel	Security	Distributions	Contact Us	Search
Archives	Calendar	Subscribe	Write for LWN	LWN.net FAQ	Sponsors

Lindows sells virus protection

Posted Feb 20, 2003 9:35 UTC (Thu) by beejaybee (guest, #1581)
In reply to: Lindows sells virus protection by rknop
Parent article: Lindows sells virus protection

"The fun thing is that it's very easy to write. "This virus scanner protects against all known extant Linux viruses! Source code available:

int main() { }
"

Sure: incomplete (there needs to be some sort of hooking into the file system to actually get files "scanned") but it's still snake oil. My thinking on this is, is it ethical to try to sell (for real money) a product they need about as much as the average fish needs a bicycle?

(Log in to post comments)

virus protection placebo

Posted Feb 23, 2003 22:30 UTC (Sun) by giraffedata (subscriber, #1954) [Link]

>is it ethical to try to sell (for real money) a product they need
>about as much as the average fish needs a bicycle?

Good point. It's the placebo question. Placebos validly treat some medical complaints. But is it fraudulent for my doctor to tell me he's prescribing a drug when he isn't? For the pharmacy to take money for a substance I could get for free? And note that the pharmacy has to charge a lot. Sugar pills at 5 cents apiece wouldn't fool anyone.

Posted Feb 27, 2003 19:43 UTC (Thu) by ikm (subscriber, #493) [Link]

Placebos cure real illnesses. But in this case there's no illness at all. Just fear, induced by the lack of relevant information on the topic. That's not a placebo because fear is not an illness, nor it is likely to cause one.