This clears nothing up [LWN.net]

This clears nothing up

Posted Nov 29, 2006 15:29 UTC (Wed) by grouch (guest, #27289)
In reply to: This clears nothing up by niner
Parent article: Novell's IRC session on the Microsoft deal

I wonder why you try so hard to see an admission by Novell, when even Microsoft says that there isn't. And they would profit immensely from one. What do you get out of it?

I wonder why you try so hard to rationalize the agreement. I wonder what you get out of it.

The patent agreement between Novell and Microsoft is wrong insofar as it encompasses GPL code distributed by Novell or Novell's customers. It conflicts with the intent and purpose of the GPL. In fact, it fits the situation anticipated by the GPL in 1991:

Finally, any free program is threatened constantly by software patents. We wish to avoid the danger that redistributors of a free program will individually obtain patent licenses, in effect making the program proprietary. To prevent this, we have made it clear that any patent must be licensed for everyone's free use or not licensed at all.
-- Preamble, GNU GPL

The only "admission by Novell" that I seek is that the patent agreement is wrong where it includes GPL'd code and is wrong where it imposes extra conditions on users (the divisive distinctions between commercial and non-commercial, developers and "end users"). Novell and Microsoft should go back to the table and correct this agreement.

(Log in to post comments)