| |||||||||||||
|
| |||||||||||||
Video editing in Linux, it *is* possibleVideo editing in Linux, it *is* possiblePosted Nov 22, 2006 8:34 UTC (Wed) by brwk (guest, #6849)Parent article: Video editing in Linux, it *is* possible
I'm very surprised you didn't take a proper look at Kino. All the extensive scripts you give just to render the result into an MPEG file are built-in options in Kino and work very nicely. Also having used both dvgrab and kino, I'd have to say I consider Kino by far the more capable and usuable capture tool of the two, offering a decent GUI to all the capture operations.
Further, it seems your excuse for not at least trying it is based on the fact that it's not made easy for you to use on your obscure distribution. While I would never question your right to use an obscure and aged distribution, I do think it is irresponsible as a reviewer to use the lack of support for a distribution to discount one of the major, most useful and effective video editing packages from review.
(Log in to post comments)
Video editing in Linux, it *is* possible Posted Nov 22, 2006 12:47 UTC (Wed) by Robin.Hill (subscriber, #4385) [Link] While I'd agree with the core of your argument, I must point out that Slackware 11 is neither obscure nor aged. While not as popular in the press as SuSE, Redhat, Mandriva, Ubuntu, et al, it has a long heritage and is still going strong, with Slackware 11 released just over a month ago.
Video editing in Linux, it *is* possible Posted Nov 22, 2006 12:57 UTC (Wed) by carlabi (guest, #34248) [Link] Kino is indeed a superb capturing tool. I would not say that it is the most useful and effective video editing packages. It doesn't come close from Cinelerra capabilities in this area.
Since Cinelerra has no problem editing raw dv, dvgrab fits my needs perfectly. I also don't recommend rendering MPEG before the editing process is over, to avoid lost of quality in the final product. I think that the Cinelerra CV team are planning to integrate the script to simplify this task.
Finally, Slackware 11 is NOT an obscure and aged distribution.
Carl (DrCurl@gmail.com)
|
|
||||||||||||