Miguel...

Miguel...

Posted Nov 17, 2006 0:35 UTC (Fri) by quintesse (subscriber, #14569)
In reply to: Miguel... by sbergman27
Parent article: On Novell and Microsoft

You do realize that Linux is GPL as well, don't you? And that you're
taking one "failed" example out of many successful GNU projects.

But anyway, what I think we owe Stallman for is that fact that he
actually made us THINK about the licenses we use. So yes, there's more
than just the GPL around, but they are there exactly because people saw
the success of GPL projects and the benefits of a GPL license, but they
just didn't agree with the ideas behind it so they made their own.

Sometimes making people stop and think is the only thing that is
necessary.

Is he the only one to do that? Of course not. Was he the first? Very
likely not. But as with many things in history sometimes the acts of
others are forgotten because one comes along that embodies everything
that they stand for.

You say that we might have been in a better position today, by the same
reasoning (which is none, because I don't seen anything to support what
you say) we could have been in a much worse position.

Because I have no idea how old you are, but I can tell you that people
where collaborating quite nicely even before existence of (or easy access
to) the Internet. Before that, you either just kept your code to
yourself, sold it or made it freeware or shareware.

The Internet has of course made collaborating with a large number of
people on large projects a lot easier but don't think it didn't happen
before.

But the whole licensing thing was just plain chaos in the free/shareware
scene, basically everybody just made up his own and there was not much
thought put into it. No direction, no ideals.

So in that aspect I think RMS (and some others like him) woke us up and
made us THINK about our licenses. And if that includes people thinking
that RMS stinks and that they'd rather sell their mother than ever use a
GPL license for their code, well more power to them.

---

(Log in to post comments)