The GPLv3 violates the 4 GNU freedoms ...

The GPLv3 violates the 4 GNU freedoms ...

Posted Oct 4, 2006 13:37 UTC (Wed) by sepreece (subscriber, #19270)
In reply to: The GPLv3 violates the 4 GNU freedoms ... by sanjoy
Parent article: Busy busy busybox

I'm sorry. I can't read this argument as anything but sophistry. Yes, the literal restriction may be the requirement to include needed keys, but the practical issue is the right to install on the device in such a way that the software continues to work, on that device, and maintain its authentication status with other services.

Even in literal terms, since the keys you mention typically involve the identity of the device as well as the software, the domain of control is clearly being extended to include the hardware. You're no longer asking for the things you need to install the software, you're asking for the things you need to install the software on a particular device, in a particular way (so that it can lie to other components or services about which version it is).

Don't bother. The FSF position is clear without the contorted rationale. Some of us disagree with it, but at least it's a straightforward position based on a philosophical position.

---

(Log in to post comments)