Where have all the reviewers gone?
Posted Sep 14, 2006 4:04 UTC (Thu) by pimlott
Parent article: Where have all the reviewers gone?
While the points about both the value and difficulty of code review are well placed, the title of this article is misleading: The reviewers have not gone anywhere, because they were never here.
Our code, we claim, is better because it has been reviewed and improved by a variety of people beyond the original author(s).
I'll let Al Viro answer
that, as he did to Eric Raymond five years ago:
* you've made a completely unwarranted assumption - that widely-used
and available code actually gets reviewed by many people. It's demonstrably
If projects are being held up by scarce reviewing resources, that's a wonderful sign that leaders are insisting upon review, not an indicator of any decline in those resources.
to post comments)