Restarting free SourceForge development
[Posted December 11, 2002 by corbet]
Back when VA Linux Systems (now VA Software) launched
SourceForge, the company put the
underlying source code out under the GPL. VA was, at that time, very much
an open source company, so releasing the code was a natural thing to do.
Since then, VA has transformed itself from an open source hardware company
to a proprietary software company based on SourceForge. So it is not all
that surprising that VA's enthusiasm for free SourceForge code releases has
waned; the last such release (from the "
alexandria-dev"
project) is dated November 4, 2001. Since then, VA has limited itself
to proprietary releases.
The free SourceForge releases are just that, however: free. And since they
are free software, there is no need to wait for VA to make new releases.
So it should come as no surprise that a number of SourceForge fork projects
have appeared. Most of these are the basis for other SourceForge-like
development sites:
- Berlios is, perhaps, the
earliest SourceForge fork still operating; this site headed off with
something like version 1.5 of the code.
- The GNU Project's Savannah site
is based on version 2.0 of the SourceForge code.
- Debian-sf, a packaging
of the code for Debian systems, uses version 2.5 - the last official
release from VA.
All of these projects have provided useful resources for the free software
community. They all have, however, gone off in their own directions to
attain their specific goals; in none of these cases has the general
development of the SourceForge code been one of those goals. (This is not
a criticism - realistic projects can only take on so much).
Thanks to a note from Rick
Moen (which is also the source for the version information above), we
have been clued in to the GForge Project,
which is trying to get development of the SourceForge code back on track.
GForge is headed up by Tim Perdue, who certainly has the right credentials
for the job: he was the original author of a good chunk of the original
SourceForge system.
GForge has started with the most recent code from the SourceForge.net CVS
server, which has been deemed version 2.61. It has since been enhanced
with Jabber support, an improved interface, a new forum system, and easier
installation. Quite
a bit of effort has also gone into cleaning up the code; optimizations for
hundreds of thousands of users have been deemed unnecessary, and "foundries
and related nonsense" have been excised from the code base. And, of
course, the whole thing is licensed under the GPL.
GForge should become the new focal point for development of the
SourceForge code. The Debian-sf project is already working with GForge;
Debian users can, with a suitable configuration file entry, install GForge
with an apt-get command. One can only hope that GForge will lead
to a new set of free software development sites popping up on the net, and
further diversification away from the "official" SourceForge site.
SourceForge remains a very expensive form of advertising for a company
which has lost interest in free software; relying on its continued
existence forever would be foolhardy.
As LWN has said before, VA has done the free software a great service by
running SourceForge for the last three years. In the long run, however, it
may turn out that the greater service was releasing the SourceForge code
under the GPL. That release has allowed the community to continue to use
and develop the SourceForge code after VA's business needs drew its
attention elsewhere. We will reap the benefits of that gift long after
SourceForge.net has shut down.
(
Log in to post comments)