LWN.net Logo

Microsoft examines the Darknet

Microsoft examines the Darknet

Posted Nov 27, 2002 10:42 UTC (Wed) by mgh (guest, #5696)
Parent article: Microsoft examines the Darknet

How can I not be cynical about this latest attempt of government or coporates to regulate something for what is supposed to be our own good.

Facts: Drug use is at an all time high despite billions of dollars spent on what are fondly called "wars on drugs". All for the good of the people, however I don't know any person who is supposed to be "protected" by these actions that would in fact support them. This is not to suggest that drug are not harmful health when used. The issue is of course that drugs are not addicitive, people are addictive.

What does this have to do with Music? Music is different in one respect - at first sight it does not seem to be a mind/mood altering chemical, but on the other hand music is the passion of many and we listen to music because we like the effect. Try not listening to any music for two weeks and then sitting down and listening to your favourite piece - startling experience.

Simple analysis would be the prison terms don't stop people trading in illegal drugs, legislation and technology control won't stop illicit trading of music.

The legislation will have the effect of harming innovation of technology, but countries other than the US will not be so restricted so they will still produce "illegal" computers without the DRM that can make them secure. I agree with the article - no way will legislation prevent the use of technology.

Behaviour is regulated not by laws, but by morals of individuals. Today moving music from cd to tape or to another format accepted. Changing the law or technology will change this perception. Attempts to control will add the thrill and make it more attractive!!!


(Log in to post comments)

Copyright © 2012, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds