LWN.net Logo

Nautilus again

Nautilus again

Posted Dec 30, 2005 17:01 UTC (Fri) by hingo (guest, #14792)
Parent article: An Evening with Jeff Waugh (Linux Journal)

I actually thought the other thing Mark was voted down on is even funnier than the naked lady:

The other time Mark was overruled by the community involved the Nautilus file manager program. When you clicked on a folder in Nautilus, a new window would pop up on the screen. People complained about how the screens would become full of windows. Mark thought it would be a great idea that when one window opened the previous window would close. This feature, at Mark's insistence, was shipped but caused an even greater number of complaints, as users wanted to know why the Nautilus window seemed to dance all over the screen.

Nerds are great people, but sometimes I just have to smile a little. The ability to completely loose touch with reality is not a trait exclusively reserved for Gnome hackers, but the Nautilus spatial file manager certainly was a good example. Here's an idea. Let's force users to open lots of windows even if they don't want to. Then when they complain, we'll "fix" this by opening one window and closing another. Then we'll remember to complain every now and then that that other desktop is bloated with unnecessary features.

Sorry, I know this is a sore topic, but it's just so funny. As developers it's important to always remind oneself, if the users are happy with something, don't break their program just because you don't have anything important to do. If something wasn't a good idea, just accept the fact and drop it, don't start "fixing" a bad idea. Keep It Simple and all that...


(Log in to post comments)

Developers, users, and things that just work without bloat

Posted Jan 5, 2006 14:41 UTC (Thu) by utoddl (subscriber, #1232) [Link]

The "Amiga User Interface Style Guide" (or some name similar to that; remember the Amiga?) had sage advice along these lines:

Don't create user options simply because you couldn't make a design decision.

Maybe that's how they achieved great multitasking in <1Mb.

Copyright © 2012, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds