MUST note if drivers are OSS - and the FSF has such a list! [LWN.net]

MUST note if drivers are OSS - and the FSF has such a list!

Posted Dec 15, 2005 16:43 UTC (Thu) by vmole (subscriber, #111)
In reply to: MUST note if drivers are OSS - and the FSF has such a list! by dwheeler
Parent article: "Just works with Linux"

Perhaps the reason he "forgot" to mention it was that it has only two entries, one of which is over a year old and is marked "unsupported" (I don't know whether that means the SD readers are unsupported under Linux, or that the driver in question is currently unsupported.)

All of which underscores the original point: it's easy to setup the structure for a database like this, and damn hard to make it actually useful.

(Log in to post comments)

MUST note if drivers are OSS - and the FSF has such a list!

Posted Dec 15, 2005 19:45 UTC (Thu) by gtaylor6 (subscriber, #19812) [Link]

[...] it's easy to setup the structure for a database like this, and damn hard to make it actually useful.

Yup.

I built linuxprinting.org, and setting up the schema, while less trivial than you might think, was by far the easy part.

Gathering the data is hard. You need to be a combination of editor and tech support person to be able to work with inexpert users to determine the status of each new device. We've got roughly 1750 entries, and it took about 10 years. That's less than one device a day, and it's not for lack of printer models to document...

One big problem is that few of these databases share data. If they were all combined, and any submission to any ended up everywhere, then all this discussion about which existing incomplete database should be used would become moot. Unfortunately, seamless data sharing requires a comparatively formal and complex schema that isn't likely to appear out of thin air.

MUST note if drivers are OSS - and the FSF has such a list!

Posted Dec 16, 2005 21:31 UTC (Fri) by liamh (subscriber, #4872) [Link]

I was going to post that linuxprinting is one such database that really works -- there's a large amount of information and it seems to be continually updated. This has been valuable to me several times.

About the FSF effort

Posted Dec 26, 2005 17:39 UTC (Mon) by johnsu01 (guest, #34757) [Link]

I have the responsibility for coordinating the FSF effort at a hardware database. Obviously we have next to nothing there at the moment.

I've been talking with some people over the last couple of weeks about ways to make it easier for people to submit information, and so I think we'll have some improvements in that area soon.

If anyone would like to chip in some volunteer time to help get this thing together, drop me a line at johns at fsf dot org with your ideas. The core principle here is to include only completely free drivers. We will be focusing on GNU/Linux systems, but will be happy to include information about free BSD systems as well when that info comes our way.