LWN.net Logo

Debian and Nexenta collide

Debian and Nexenta collide

Posted Nov 9, 2005 20:18 UTC (Wed) by Duncan (guest, #6647)
Parent article: Debian and Nexenta collide

When I read the GPL complaint, the syslibs exemption was my first
reaction. The "shipping with" clause didn't occur to me. After I read a
bit further, however, I could see the legal argument, altho the irony of a
GPL restriction allowing allowing use on a closed system but not on a
system composed of Free software, certainly bites!

Then the split solution occurred to me, just before I got to that part of
the article. After reading the full article, I still don't see the
problem. Certainly, it shouldn't be difficult to script a solution in the
installer that downloads (if necessary) and unpacks dpkg and the like in
place, making them part of a core-package that provides the necessary
dependencies and pre-stuffs the dependency database as necessary. I just
don't quite see the problem, at least not as anything at a level
comparable to setting up an entire OS, something they're already taking
on. It's just one more thing an installer must manage, on top of the
others it already manages. If they're using the Debian installer and
that's GPLed, creating one's own installer isn't a problem others haven't
tackled already, either.

Duncan


(Log in to post comments)

Debian and Nexenta collide

Posted Nov 10, 2005 4:14 UTC (Thu) by AJWM (subscriber, #15888) [Link]

That's pretty much the way un-open Solaris has handled it. Any GNU or other GPL'd utilities are shipped on an entirely separate disc, so the OS components do not "accompan[y] the [GPLd] executable[s]". They are packaged such that Sun's own install mechanisms can be used to install them, avoiding the dpkg bootstrap issue.

Debian and Nexenta collide

Posted Nov 11, 2005 4:38 UTC (Fri) by kimoto (subscriber, #5244) [Link]

What about when I turned on some new hardware from Sun and found some incarnation of of Solaris 8 on it, including working versions of some GPL'd programs like gzip and bash?

Copyright © 2008, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds
Powered by Rackspace Managed Hosting.