LWN.net Logo

Nexenta (Debian-based GNU/Solaris) launches

Nexenta (Debian-based GNU/Solaris) launches

Posted Nov 3, 2005 21:51 UTC (Thu) by hazelsct (subscriber, #3659)
In reply to: Nexenta (Debian-based GNU/Solaris) launches by bajw
Parent article: Nexenta (Debian-based GNU/Solaris) launches

Please describe how Solaris under the new license is unfree. It's not GPL-compatible, but neither is MacOS X, which has a Debian port (fink).


(Log in to post comments)

Nexenta (Debian-based GNU/Solaris) launches

Posted Nov 4, 2005 20:18 UTC (Fri) by kreutzm (subscriber, #4700) [Link]

AFAIK fink is not a Debian port but just uses apt / dpkg to install software (i.e. uses Debian tools).

Nexenta (Debian-based GNU/Solaris) launches

Posted Nov 10, 2005 3:21 UTC (Thu) by josh (guest, #17465) [Link]

The Freeness of the CDDL is one issue. The far more relevant issue, however, is that the CDDL is not GPL-compatible, which means that Nexenta *may not* distribute GPL software (such as most of the Debian core packages) linked to the CDDLed Solaris libraries.

The fink project can distribute GPLed software for MacOSX because the fink project does not distribute OSX itself, and may thus take advantage of the exception for system libraries. The Nexenta project distributes GPLed software together with the CDDLed system libraries that it links together, which is not permitted. (This exception was designed for when a completely Free system did not exist, so that GNU software could be used to replace components of a proprietary system piece by piece, but proprietary vendors would not have an exception permitting them to distribute GPLed software linked to their proprietary libraries.)

Copyright © 2008, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds