Development [LWN.net]

Enter TurboGears

October 25, 2005

This article was contributed by Matt Gushee

The hottest new thing in Web development these days is TurboGears (TG), a "full-stack" Web development framework implemented in Python with model-view-controller as its key design principle. Development is proceeding rapidly: the first public release, 0.5, appeared on September 17, and the product has since gone through several iterations and now stands at version 0.8a4. It might seem an impossible pace, but TurboGears is not so much a new product as a new assembly of existing products. As the project Web site puts it:

[TurboGears]

TurboGears takes the best components available and combines them into one easy-to-install, documented whole. TurboGears includes parts that join the pieces together and make them work together seamlessly, but doesn't obscure each included project.

The meaning of "full-stack" is somewhat in the eye of the beholder, of course. But by most standards, TG does a good job of providing for all tiers of a typical Web application. Its major components are:

SQLObject: an Object-Relational Mapping (ORM) library
CherryPy: a lower-level Web application framework with a built-in HTTP server
Kid: a templating system that embeds Python code in well-formed XML documents
MochiKit: a rich but lightweight JavaScript library that supports asynchronous HTTP requests

Additional components provide support for unit testing, XML document navigation, form validation, and conversion between Python data structures and JavaScript Object Notation (JSON). Third-party extensions have started appearing, too, like the CatWalk model browser.

At first glance, TG looks a lot like Ruby on Rails. Certainly, the projects are similar in their goals and high-level architectures. And it is fair to say that TG is largely inspired by Ruby on Rails--but there are differences. For example, TG comes with built-in support for JavaScript Object Notation (JSON); combined with asynchronous HTTP requests, this facilitates AJAX development--or perhaps we should say "AJAJ"--by substituting a simpler data format for XML.

The templating systems are also significantly different: Kid templates consist of well-formed XML (often XHTML in practice) with Python embedded in attributes and element content, while Rails uses Embedded Ruby (ERuby), which uses non-XML tags to embed Ruby in (X)HTML or other text files.

One of the most important differences, however, is in the ORM layer: the ActiveRecord package used in Rails provides an object layer over an existing database, whereas Python's SQLObject also allows the database to be generated based on Python objects.

This is not to suggest that TG is superior in every respect. Rails has a "scaffolding" feature, which automatically generates CRUD (Create, Retrieve, Update, Delete) operations. There is also an ActionMailer package which provides e-mail services for applications. In other words, while TurboGears and Rails have many similarities, they are far from identical.

Beyond the differences in features, there remains the highly subjective matter of language choice. Even if TG were simply a clone of Rails, surely it is a wonderful thing that developers can implement architectures in the language of their choice. Isn't that what open source is all about? And the community appears to have ample energy for creating and maintaining Web frameworks.

To my mind, what really stands out about TG is the clear vision and the sense of competence that its developers are communicating. There are many technically sound and interesting Web tools available, but they often suffer from poor documentation and worse marketing. While its feature set is highly attractive in itself, it is the project's superior presentation that makes it likely to attract a broad following.

Additional Resources

TurboGears home page
TurboGears defined
TurboGears: Python on Rails? (O'Reilly)
Python Web Framework Niches (Groovie.org)
Blue Sky on Mars (Kevin Dangoor)
Rails everywhere (Slashdot)
CatWalk home page
Turbo Gears: Python in the battle (Ajaxian.com)
TurboGears: is it really worth looking at? (O'Reilly)

Comments (2 posted)

System Applications

Database Software

MySQL 5.0 released

The first MySQL 5.0 production release is out - click below for the full announcement. This major release adds a number of SQL features (views, stored procedures, triggers, etc.), some new storage engines, and more. The what's new page has more information.

Full Story (comments: 2)

MySQL 4.1.15 has been released

Version 4.1.15 of the MySQL database has been released. "This is a bugfix release for the current production version."

Full Story (comments: none)

PostgreSQL 8.1 Beta 4 available

Version 8.1 Beta 4 of the PostgreSQL database is available for testing.