What to merge for 2.6.13?

Some of the decisions are not particularly controversial. Andrew is likely to merge the OCFS2 filesystem, some Xen precursor patches, execute in place support, software suspend support for SMP systems, some kernel timer performance improvements, various KProbes updates, the RapidIO subsystem, some scheduler tweaks, and some memory management work. Nobody has really complained about the inclusion of any of these patches (yet), so their path into the kernel might be relatively smooth.

One patch which has gotten surprising support is kexec, which was first covered here in November, 2002. The ability to quickly boot a new kernel without going through the system firmware is nice, but the real payoff for kexec comes when it is combined with kernel crash dumps. Crash dumps can be a useful diagnostic tool, especially for vendors who are trying to track down a bizarre crash which only occurs at a customer's site. So various distributors have included some sort of crash dump capability in their kernels for some time. These patches will typically write kernel memory to a disk or network device, then reboot the system.

The approaches taken to crash dumps so far share one significant problem: they all rely on the kernel to create its own dump. But this is a kernel which has just gone into panic mode; it is not in a stable state. The chances of an oopsing kernel completing a satisfactory crash dump are not all that high (Arjan van de Ven estimates that it works about 10% of the time). The real problem, however, is the risk involved in allowing an unstable kernel to continue performing I/O; there is a very real possibility that a (corrupted) crash dump could end up being written on top of something that the owner would have preferred to keep.

The kexec approach gets around this problem by rebooting the system before performing the dump. The normal, production kernel is configured to set aside a small range of memory, which it never uses. Instead, a different kernel is loaded into that memory; this kernel will be small, and configured to do little other than performing crash dumps. If the system should panic, kexec is used to immediately boot into the crash dump kernel. This kernel, which will be starting fresh and in a known state, can then write the contents of memory to some sort of permanent store before rebooting into a new production kernel. This approach is safer and more reliable; the mailing list discussion has been favorable enough that kexec/kdump appears likely to be merged.

The reiser4 filesystem has sat in the -mm tree for some time, and Andrew indicated that he might merge it this time around. Reiser4 has run into trouble into the past, mostly as a result of its "file as a directory" semantics which change how Linux works, can confuse tools, and, crucially, can lead to system deadlocks. This feature has been disabled for now, but there is still opposition to merging reiser4 into the mainline.

The main issue this time around would appear to be the plugin architecture used by reiser4. Plugins can be used to change the behavior of the filesystem in many ways, from adding compression to completely changing how the file is laid out on disk. The plugin mechanism is a key part of Hans Reiser's longer-term vision of how filesystems should work; he hopes to eventually move all kinds of functionality into the filesystem level. The kernel developers, however, do not think that this sort of mechanism should be built into a filesystem; instead, much of what plugins do belongs in the VFS layer. So they would like to see reiser4 slimmed down into a much smaller, dumber system, with the plugin capability added on top of it and made available for other filesystems as well.

Hans is resisting making this (large) change; he asks that the review process take a different tack:

Things appear to be at a standoff which could block the inclusion of reiser4 for some time.

Yet another change under consideration is configurable clock frequencies for the i386 and ia-64 architectures. The current value (1KHz) turns out not to be optimal for all users; lower clock frequencies can improve throughput on some systems at the cost of coarser timer resolution and possibly increased latencies. There have been complaints about the new default (250Hz) and the fact that the patch is going in at all when more sweeping changes to the timer system (such as the dynamic tick patch) are waiting on the wings. Your editor's guess is that the patch will be merged, but the default may be changed to keep the current HZ value.

FUSE (user-space filesystems) is being discussed again. FUSE has run into opposition due to the way it overrides the file permissions checking done at the VFS level. There does not appear to be any solution to this issue that pleases everybody, so it is hard to say where this one might go. It is possible that FUSE will be merged, but without its particular permissions behavior - a solution which would leave a number of FUSE users still needing to apply a patch to get the behavior they want.

It didn't appear on Andrew's list, but the removal of devfs has also been a discussion item. Andrew didn't entirely like the full patch set which completely removed devfs from the kernel; he wondered what would happen if enough people complained and devfs had to be restored at some point in the future. So the current approach is to simply remove the devfs configuration option, making the functionality inaccessible. Eventually, if no major problems turn up, the code can be removed for real.