LWN.net Logo

Public Domain Enhancement Act reintroduced

Public Domain Enhancement Act reintroduced

Posted May 25, 2005 13:55 UTC (Wed) by sphealey (guest, #1028)
In reply to: Public Domain Enhancement Act reintroduced by khim
Parent article: Public Domain Enhancement Act reintroduced

> What is the excuse? It is that the author who produced that book
> has had the profit of it long enough, and therefore the Government
> takes a profit which does not belong to it and generously gives it
> to the 88,000,000 of people.

Of course, it was the government in the Hobbesian sense that prevented the general public from just taking the work in the first place, as was done for the first 10,000 years of human history, by creating the concept of copyright, granting it, and then enforcing it against the citizenry for the agreed-upon term. Society's return on investment for that forebearance is that the author not complain when the work enters the public domain at the end of the term - otherwise, it would have entered the public domain the first time he published it.

sPh


(Log in to post comments)

Public Domain Enhancement Act reintroduced

Posted May 25, 2005 23:13 UTC (Wed) by XERC (guest, #14626) [Link]

I agree. But, there is a question, WHAT IS A
GOVERNMENT?

Governmet, that should be us, the cociety, and,
at least in eastern europe, it tends to be us, the
simple society. You know, each nation has the
government that it deserves, so, if the government
screws up, we've got nobody else to complain but
ourselves: why weren't we active enough to piecefully
enforce and cultivate(by lobbying, by
providing technical means that help to
enchance democracy, etc.) the kind of laws and understandings
that we like.

Public Domain Enhancement Act reintroduced

Posted May 25, 2005 23:24 UTC (Wed) by XERC (guest, #14626) [Link]

UUps, I forgot to mention. That's waht we're
exactly doing: some of us are developing new
forum related software, cooperating with
E-government project people, to
enchance and X(I don't know the term in english, but
it means: "to take in to use and to be used to using
it".) public discussion about politics and to turn
the debate between general public and the government
a daily and natural piece of our decideing process.

I'm sorry for the spelling mistakes. Currently I don't
have a spell checker available, as I use Knoppix 3.6
(and the Kate spell checker didn't work).

Copyright © 2008, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds