Re: [PATCH] In-kernel module loader 1/7

In message <E181Tcc-0003k0-00@starship> you write:
> On Tuesday 15 October 2002 05:25, Rusty Russell wrote:
> > It won't quite work if the hooks can sleep.  You can say "don't sleep"
> > or have a wedge which does the "try_inc_mod_count()" then calls into
> > the module (and returns some default if it can't inc the module count).
> 
> Right.  By coincidence, I found myself thinking about this very problem
> as I re-materialized this morning.  If TRY_INC_MOD_COUNT also ors a flag
> (which it does now, for other reasons) then:
> 
>    1) Clear the mod_inc flag
>    2) Unhook the function hooks
>    3) Schedule on each CPU
>    4) If the mod_inc flag is set, repeat from (1)
> 
> This should perform acceptably well, and would only be done in cases
> where the existing TRY_INC_MOD_COUNT strategy can't be used.

This is basically the same technique used in my current patch.  We set
module->live = 0, sychronize_kernel(), then look at reference count.
In this case, instead of setting a flag, try_inc_mod_count (aka
try_module_get()) bumps the refcount, to similar effect to the flag.

> > You can't disable preemption before calling in, because there is no
> > way to sleep with preemption disabled. 8(
> 
> Why is that harder than bumping a counter that makes preempt_schedule
> return without doing anything?

Definitely.  We could simply allow schedule() to be called when
preempt is disabled, but it's a useful debugging tool to not do that.
And, of course, disabling preemption widely kind of defeats the point
of having a preemptive kernel 8(

I really wish the security guys had gone down the macro path, with
something like

#define security_check(func, default_val, ...)
	({ if (try_inc_mod_count(security_ops->owner))
		security_ops->func(__VA_ARGS__);
	   else
		default_val;
	})

This also allows the whole thing to vanish if
CONFIG_SECURITY_CAPABILITIES=n, and allows more flexibility for
schemes like "always run with preemption disabled around security ops"
or whatever, rather than having to search for all the references to
security_ops.

Cheers,
Rusty.
--
  Anyone who quotes me in their sig is an idiot. -- Rusty Russell.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/