LWN.net Logo

GNOME and KDE priorities

GNOME and KDE priorities

Posted Feb 3, 2005 15:39 UTC (Thu) by rwmj (subscriber, #5474)
In reply to: GNOME and KDE priorities by niran
Parent article: GNOME and KDE priorities

Actually, going back 5 minutes is useful for me since
I tend to watch DVDs in small parts (while exercising),
but I take your point that it may not be for everyone.

So let's look at the rewind issue in general. On Apple's
DVD player, rewinding happens at a constant rate (say,
2x or 16x), but to set this rate you have to go through
an awkward two-level menu. On my real DVD player, rewind
begins slowly and gets faster the longer you hold the button
down. On my PVR, you press the button multiple times
to go 2x, 4x, 6x ... faster.

None of these interfaces is especially smart. The Apple
one is the most annoying, but even the PVR interface
(which I like best of them) still makes it hard to go
from fast rewind to slow forward, which is an obvious
thing to want to do (think about when you "overshoot").

In this case, multiple buttons makes an awful lot of sense,
something like:

[Rewind slow] [Forward slow]
[Rewind fast] [Forward fast]

(I only ever want to go slowly or quickly; going at
intermediate speeds is never really useful).

This still doesn't solve the "how do I get to a particular
point on the disk", or "how do I go back 5 minutes", but
if the time counter was a simple entry form which could
be modified by typing in numbers, that would solve all of
those problems and more.

Rich.


(Log in to post comments)

GNOME and KDE priorities

Posted Feb 3, 2005 15:44 UTC (Thu) by rwmj (subscriber, #5474) [Link]

Oh, and the other really really stupid thing about
Apple's rewind mechanism, is that it's time sensitive.
Press the button quickly, and it goes back a chapter.
Hold down the button and it starts to rewind.

Time sensitive buttons are a usability no-no, and
bad from an accessibility point too (although Apple's
DVD player has so many other accessibility problems,
that one extra hardly matters).

Why couldn't they just have had a separate button for
"go back a chapter"?

Rich.

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds