Beat spam using hashcash (IBM developerWorks) [LWN.net]

Beat spam using hashcash (IBM developerWorks)

Posted Nov 12, 2004 22:19 UTC (Fri) by giraffedata (subscriber, #1954)
In reply to: Beat spam using hashcash (IBM developerWorks) by ballombe
Parent article: Beat spam using hashcash (IBM developerWorks)

There are lots of different ways spamming happens. It will probably take lots of separate solutions to get rid of it completely. The trojaned spambot problem will probably be addressed with some kind of security solution, whereas no amount of security will stop someone from sending spam from his own machine in his own name. A resource burn might be effective there, though.

However, this is completely unpractical for mailing-lists.

These solutions usually have a feature where you can excuse expected email from the payment. Maybe by password or authenticated source.

The resource burn is particularly effective for those emails you aren't expecting and come from strangers but that are nonetheless valuable to you. For example, an advertisement for a new product you actually want. If the advertiser takes care to selectively send the ad to people who might actually be interested, he can afford the resource burn.

I question the ethic of forcing people to waste resource to send an email

Yeah, me too. It would be much better if we could find a way to make this expenditure by the sender go somewhere besides into thin air. Like to the recipient to compensate him for reading the email. Or to charity.

But this kind of payment is prevalent in our society. Think of all the resources that are allocated according to how long a person is willing to stand in line. Standing in line for 6 hours is the way you prove you want it more than the guy behind you, but it's a total waste of resources.

(Log in to post comments)